Here is Elysian Organics response to Etsy Herbivore Botanicals claim about us copying her listings.
Elysian Organics has attempted numerous times to post this exact information on Callin' Out on Etsy, but they would not post it.
Read at the end to see the exact convos that took place on Etsy between Herbivore Botanicals and Elysian Organics in October 2011 --- screen shots and photoshop will do wonders :) ---- we contacted Herbivore Botanicals and she completely admits to copying photo styling of Elysian Organics and various other Etsy shops, and also admits to using text directly from Elysian Organics listings.
Here it is December 2011 and she says WHAT? about Elysian Organics on Callin' Out on Etsy?????
If this isn't incriminating evidence to the BS both Herbivore Botanicals and Callin' Out on Etsy is spilling out, we don't know what is,
---- look at Herbivore Botanicals sold items at the link below and you will see exactly what we are talking about and why we contacted her directly : http://www.etsy.com/shop/HerbivoreBotanicals/sold?page=8
And, did you notice how completely different her soaps and presentation was before her sudden big change ---- when she wasn't selling hardly any?
She also decided to copy Rocky Top's Soap Label pretty closely:
Herbivore Botanical: http://www.etsy.com/transaction/62251834
Rocky Top: http://www.etsy.com/transaction/64936266
and many of her new clay soap recipes seem to be complete copies of their soaps as well.
Herbivore Botanicals has changed her soap wraps, her soap listings, & her photography styling many times in October- was it because the heat she was receiving from us & all the other Etsy sellers she admits to copying?
Here are just a couple of our older style listings from last year. If you viewed the link above of Etsy Herbivore Botanicals older sold listings, you will hopefully understand why we contacted her:
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/53986653
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/54033195
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/59015751
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/54823877
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/58729722
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/54941680
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/55251721
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/52515082
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/51529257
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/51529255
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/51529256
And, Herbivore Botanicals claim regarding Elysian Organics copying the usage of craft boxes for gift soap packages....we've been doing that far longer then her, since she only starting using them in December. See our sold listings below with sold dates of August 2011:
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/55298516
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/56194216
Also, Herbivore Botanicals claim that Elysian Organics is copying her soap samples....see our sold listings that go as far back as June 2011. We've been using muslin bags, wrapping in paper & washi tape since we opened!
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/54067382
http://www.etsy.com/transaction/52660784
Case in point that Callin' Out on Etsy has no credibility and will let anyone say anything to eliminate competition. The fact that Elysian Organics has given this information directly to Callin' out on Etsy and they refuse to post it, only shows proof that Callin' Out on Etsy is one huge biased bitchy forum.
ReplyDeleteThis is not surprising to me. Callin' out on Etsy is not respectable or responsible. They have went as far as to give out Etsy seller's addresses and phone numbers to ensue people to harass these people even more than they do on their Callin Out on Etsy site. I am an Etsy seller and I have purchased from Elysian Organics. I absolutely love their soaps and their body butter is heavenly. Not to mention, they are some of the nicest sellers I have encountered to date!
ReplyDeleteI love Elysian Organics and what has happened to this shop since they have opened on Etsy is disgusting! Callin' Out on Etsy is a bunch of bitches just as they self proclaim they are. OMG, and this new claim made by this crazy person, Julia Anne Wills of Herbivore Botanicals is downright inexcusable! I love how Julia of Herbivore Botanicals states that Elysian Organics is immature and rude, but if you read the convos that transpired between them, Elysian is nice and trying to warn her about people on Etsy and she is a COMPLETE BITCH back to them. "F U and your family" she says to them" What a nutjob. Sure hope she gets what is coming to her. Sad that Callin' Out on Etsy is too weak to admit they have messed up and apologize to Elysian Organics for attempting yet again to ruin their reputation.
ReplyDeleteI want to personally vouch for Elysian Organics. Marty and Christine are an amazing co-effort in creating high quality therapeutic skin products. I am a personal friend and a dermatologist. They have consulted with me regarding the creation of many of their products. They personally create skin care products for individuals to help combat widely known skin conditions. Many of my clients use their products and find relief and comfort. They are wonderful people and are honest to the core.
ReplyDeleteI cannot believe someone is so shady out there and such a liar! To try to ruin someone's credibility and say such harsh untrue things on some crazy site which I have never seen before until now. Callin' out on Etsy is obviously a bunch of losers who just will jump AT ANY chance to be a bunch of evil bitches. WEIRD AND SICK PEOPLE OUT THERE! This IS just proof that they will post anything at all, even when they've been given proof that it's completely untrue! They seriously need to get lives and so does this Julia Anne Wills of Herbivore Botanicals. Have these people no shred of integrity????!!!!! How can this even be going on is what I want to know.
ReplyDeleteElysian Organics is a wonderful shop, they are such nice people and this is what they have to keep being subjected to because of what???
I say SHEER JEALOUSY! This Herbivore Botanicals shop is clearly jealous to the core, hasn't a shred of honesty or talent going for her, loves to make false accusations, and turns out is just one big LOSER LIAR!!!
GET LIVES YOU LOSERS and have some INTEGRITY!
What the F? is all I have to say about this. Pathetic, Pathetic, Pathetic. All this mudslinging by some crazy chick who is a complete and total liar. She admits to copying so many different Etsy shops (including Elysian Organics). She even admitted to using exact words from their listing! She has the gaul to then accuse them of copying her. What the F? again!!
ReplyDeleteI tried to defend Elysian Organics last time the were on Callin' out on Etsy because I know them personally, have been to their house numerous times and have seen them with my own eyes making soap and all their bath & body products. NONE OF MY POSTS APPEARED!
Callin' Out on Etsy is a completely biased site hellbent on taking down certain people and filter what they want to appear and what they don't so they can have exactly what they want to occur. If they were a fair and legitimate site, they wouldn't filter comments that can counteract what they are saying about shops.
And, the fact that they gave out personal information (phone nubmbers and addresses) of seller's that they were trying to destroy is a complete invasion of privacy, slanderous, and how it isn't illegal is beyond me. I have also lost all respect for Wordpress because they allow this to go on. I also can't believe Etsy allows this behavior!
Shame on Callin' out on Etsy and shame on this lying seller Herbivore Botanicals.
Do not be fooled by the false claims and lies they are saying about Elysian Organics. They are a reputable seller and are great folks to know.
Natasha Dembinski
You've got to be kidding me ---- I've seriously had it with Callin' Out on Etsy and their bullshit. They've tried going after this shop before, created alias accounts claiming to BE this shop and posting a bunch of crazy statements NOT EVEN MADE by Christine and Marty.
ReplyDeleteThey are disgusting, vile creatures AND completely manipulating the truth! Every time Callin' Out on Etsy comes up with ALL DIGNIFIED ETSY SELLERS they think they're disgusting.
Has anyone ever seen the freaks on Callin' Out on Etsy and their Etsy shops???? They are absolute SHIT and that is why they do what they do. They don't sell anything on Etsy because their stuff/"artistic creations" -- LOL -- are CRAP, CRAP, CRAP!!! Did I mention what they sell is CRAP? LOL again. And this is why they have all this time on their hands to go after & attempt to destroy actual sellers on Etsy.
Jesus, there was a forum on Etsy where everyone thought that Callin' Out on Etsy was finally gone because of them posting people's personal information and everyone was SO F'ING OVERJOYED! Any decent person hates them and if you notice -- it's the same hating bitches that comment over and over again on that site. Yes, they are jealous hating bitches (their personal claim) who need to get a life and spend their time hating on people actually creating art and something worth selling and buying on Etsy.
Go away losers once and for all.
Oh, and Herbivore Botanicals is a liar just like them and is just as disgusting for making friends w/the antichrist and trying to hurt Elysian Organics.
Newsflash Herbivore Botanicals -- you will never sell as much as Elysian Organics no matter how hard you try to hurt them and their business. And, get a life you LYING LOSER.